Arc-Flash risk

It is the result of an electrical short circuit conducted through the air. It is a violent release of thermal energy from an electrical source, which can cause serious or even fatal burns or injuries. On an electrical panel, the risks of an Arc Flash become a major concern starting at 220 volts AC.

The difference lies in the consequence related to the accident. In the case of electric shock, it refers to injuries caused by an electric current passing through the body, whereas electrocution refers to death resulting from an electric shock.

An Arc Flash can reach up to 18,000°C, which is about three times the heat of the sun’s surface.

The consequences of exposure to an Arc Flash are multiple :

• Burns : The heat and flames from a massive explosion can cause second- and/or third-degree burns. Projections of molten metal can also cause severe burns.
• Hearing loss : The sound wave can reach 165 dB, comparable to that of an aircraft taking off, and can lead to hearing degradation or loss.
• Eye injuries : An intense light flash, with UV radiation, can cause eye injuries.
• Respiratory disorders : Toxic vapors and fumes (such as vaporized copper) can cause damage after inhalation.

An Arc Flash can occur in various environments, whether related to electrical installations or structures, starting from a nominal voltage of 220 Volts AC. Here are some examples :

• Production : Power plants : nuclear, hydroelectric, thermal, or wind.
• Transmission : Medium and high voltage electrical networks, between different substations.
• Electrical substations : High-voltage current transformed into low-voltage current for distribution.
• Electric traction : Railway networks.
• Factories and industrial installations : Significant energy demand for production.
• Distribution : For low-voltage electrical networks.
• Technical rooms and electrical panels : Electrical distribution panels, circuit breakers, control panels.
• Electric mobility : Cars, trucks, forklifts, and other electric or hybrid vehicles.
• Data centres : Large number of servers and electrical installations with high energy demands.

It is crucial to follow safety and maintenance protocols and to wear appropriate PPE to protect users from the consequences of accidents and to minimize Arc Flash risks in these environments.

A Flash Arc can occur when electricity jumps across a gap between two conductors or between a conductor and a conductive surface (such as the ground or a metal enclosure). Several conditions can lead to an Arc Flash :

• Short circuit : A short circuit between two conductors can create an electric arc. This short circuit can be caused by improperly used tools, exposed wires, damaged insulation, or conductive objects falling into electrical equipment.
• Accidental contact : Accidental contact of a tool or another object with live conductors can cause an arc flash (such as the dropping of tools or accidental contact with electrical systems). This can happen during maintenance or repair work. An Arc Flash can occur with or without human presence.
• Insulation failures : Failures or degradation of the insulation around electrical conductors can allow electricity to jump through the air, resulting in an Arc Flash.
• Accumulation of dust or debris : Dust, debris, or metallic contaminants can accumulate on conductive surfaces, creating conductive paths that promote electrical arcs.
• Corrosion : Corrosion of conductors or connections can increase electrical resistance and generate heat, which can trigger an Arc Flash.
• Moisture : Moisture or condensation can create a conductive path between conductors, facilitating the formation of an arc.
• Overvoltage or overcurrent : Surges or excessive currents, due to equipment failure or lightning, for example, can cause an arc flash by overheating components and creating short circuits.
• Improper handling of equipment : Incorrect opening or closing of switches, breakers, or other energized equipment can generate arcs.

From 220 Volts AC.

One might think that in LV (Low Voltage), there is no exposure to Arc Flash, but that’s incorrect ! Even in ELV (Extra Low Voltage), the risk is still present.

There are several :

• The intensity of the electrical arc, taking into account :
  • Network voltage
  • Current intensity / Amperage
  • Inter-electrode gap
  • Confined environment
• The duration of the electrical arc : or the exposure time
• Working distance : proximity to the source of the Flash Arc
• Improperly worn PPE : improper use of PPE can exacerbate the risks

It defines the protection requirements – which means that it :

• Allows the definition of the PPE protection level.
• Allows the definition of the protection class : APC1 (Arc Protection Class 1) or APC2 (Arc Protection Class 2).
• Defines the incident energy level for a given electrical installation (ATPV and/or ELIM value expressed in cal/cm²).

It is important not to forget the notion of responsibility – the employer must request this analysis from qualified individuals or organisations.

Only a recognized organisation or qualified individuals are authorized to carry out the risk analysis. The employer must request the analysis from these entities to define the protection requirements.

The incident energy related to an Arc Flash is expressed in cal/cm² (calories per square centimetre).

No, it is not possible to establish a link between ATPV (Arc Thermal Performance Value) and APC (Arc Protection Class) because they are two distinct test methods (not the same testing setups, nor the same measurement units in the results).

OPEN ARC Method : EC 61482-1-1

Determines the ATPV and ELIM ratings of PPE in cal/cm² (American principle).

This is the most representative testing method, closest to real-world conditions. It simulates thermal effects on the body, expressed in cal/cm².

Corresponds to a wide range of incident energy levels.

BOX TEST Method : IEC 61482-1-2

Defines two PPE protection classes, based on the electrical installation’s intensity (European principle) :

APC 1* : 4 kA for 0.5 s at 30 cm
APC 2* : 7 kA for 0.5 s at 30 cm

A test focused on current intensity/density, qualifying PPE into two categories – only up to 7 kA. Not suitable above 7 kA for electrical installations.

NB : It does not reflect actual thermal effects on the body. Applies only to electrical installations.

*Arc Protection Class

Yes, there is a link because both values are obtained using the same test method, but they are two different interpretations of the result.

• ATPV = Arc Thermal Performance Value

→ The maximum thermal energy the PPE can withstand with a 50 % probability of second-degree burns. Expressed in cal/cm².

• ELIM = Incident Energy Limit

→ The maximum thermal energy the PPE can withstand with only a 1 % probability of second-degree burns. Expressed in cal/cm².

Follow the recommendations in the product-specific instructions for use.